Phantom India (1969)
Episodes
Episode 1The Impossible CameraAt the outset of the first episode of Phantom India, Malle’s issue concerning what is true about India is explicitly addressed. He reminds us, visually, that much of our understanding of India comes from the 2% of the population that is English-speaking. But these interpreters are employing Western-learned categories and constructions and consequently seeing India through a reductive Western cultural lens. Their testimony, Indian though it is, is suspect. Malle states that it is his intention to explore India, as much as possible, without preconceived prejudices. He has no planned itinerary and will go and photograph wherever the opportunities lead him.
Episode 2A Barbarian in MadrasEpisode 2 of *Phantom India* focuses on what Louis Malle encountered in Madras (Chennai), highlighting the contrasts of traditional India. The episode explores Tamil culture through scenes of a centuries-old ceremony crowded with thousands, a family planning clinic, and a film studio making folk-lore musicals. It also visits the Kalakshetra dance school, where dance is a language, prayer and invocation to God, and concludes with an extended contemplation of Indian dance culture.
Episode 3Holy IndiaIn Episode 3 of Phantom India, Louis Malle attempts to come to grips with a core feature of Indian civilization: its deeply-felt and unabiding spirituality. In fact with due consideration and respect for all the dedicated religious practitioners in various parts of the globe, it seems that Indians are the most religious people on earth. But how can one convey that spirituality in a one-hour film? Since it is always difficult to convey spiritual notions via the concrete imagery of film, the task of taking on of the vastness of India’s never-ending spiritual journey would seem to be hopelessly daunting. Despite these long odds, though, Malle’s documentary investigation here does offer some interesting insights.
Episode 4Dream and RealityDrifting through the numberless villages of southern India, Louis Malle finds himself in a timeless, fantastic, almost surrealist world. This episode moves from the Coromandel coast to Malabar and through four sections, each beginning with dreamy appearances of a particular activity before the narrator draws attention to its less pleasant reality. Kerala is like a dream, with exotic lagoons, game reserves and palm-fringed beaches—a tropical Paradise Lost. At the same time, it is a battleground for Capitalism and Maoism, where Communists are split into three parties and democracy and collectivism wrestle with the traditions of a country that by nature rejects them both.
Episode 5Invisible FrontiersThis episode focuses on life in traditional Indian villages, where Louis Malle has been told the essence of India can be found. Although the country has a number of large urban areas, he notes that 80% of its population lives in rural villages. Malle and his crew travel to a village in Haryana, just north of Delhi, to film its inhabitants. He first interviews an American Peace Corps volunteer who has come to introduce modern farming techniques, hoping Western technology can contribute positively to village life and bridge the gap between the modern West and the traditional East. The challenge is considerable: there are only 700 such volunteers for more than 560,000 Indian villages. The film also explores caste, which, although officially abolished, continues to exert a strong influence on Indian social life. Malle finds that Indians are reluctant to answer questions about it. For Hindus, caste divisions are a natural expression of their vision of the universe: religious boundaries that run through minds and hearts, rather than across the land, and that are natural in India but difficult for the West to comprehend.
Episode 6Cults, Creeds and ClansTurning aside from the traditional India of the Hindus, Louis Malle explores the India of forgotten tribes and tiny sects. In Episode 6, he encounters five social groups whose customs lie outside his principal focus: understanding the mystery of Indian culture. Two visions of Utopia emerge: the Ashram at Pondicherry, whose disciples claim yoga reveals the ultimate meaning of life, and the Todas, whose peaceful life is described as free of laws, leaders and class divisions, and marked by sexual freedom. Their only problem, the account suggests, is that they are doomed by the advance of civilisation. The episode’s diverse customs and lifestyles reflect how Indian society has largely tolerated and provided a peaceful home for difference.
Episode 7BombayAll 7 episodesBombay. Louis Malle’s four-month filming sojourn in India, which resulted in Phantom India, comes to an end here. The final installment, Episode 7, is Malle’s last lap through India, and already the city smacks of the West. Much of the footage consists of opportunistic, seemingly random street scenes, atmospheric images set against Malle’s commentary. Bombay is a city on the move, in the middle of an economic boom. Parsee industrialists, Muslim craftsmen, and immigrant labourers from the South all meet in this cosmopolitan city, whose slums are as poverty-stricken as those of Calcutta, but whose modern factories, oil refineries, and traffic problems show the shadow of the West. Malle’s commentary goes beyond Bombay, offering his view of India’s current state and future directions. Less structured than in previous episodes, it touches on six scattered topics. It is where Hinduism meets industrialisation, where East goes West, where the India of yesterday and today meets the India of tomorrow. But what kind of tomorrow?
Cast & Crew
Similar titles



















