Cast
- Allison WilliamsPeter Pan


- Christopher WalkenCaptain Hook


- Christian BorleGeorge Darling / Smee


- Kelli O'HaraMrs. Darling


- Taylor LoudermanWendy Darling


- Minnie DriverAdult Wendy Darling / Narrator


- Jake LucasJohn Darling


- John AllynMichael Darling

- Alanna SaundersTiger Lily


- Caitlin HoulahanJane Darling


- Jason GotayTootles


- Alan H. GreenCookson


- Jacob GuzmanTwin 1


- David GuzmanTwin 2


- F. Michael HaynieSlightly


- Austin LeschBill Jukes

- Chris McCarrellNibs

- Michael ParkCecco


- Bryce RynessStarkey

- Ryan SteeleCurly


- Chris SullivanNoodler


- Ryan AndesAdmiral Crichton


- Dyllón BurnsidePrickles


- John Arthur GreeneRobert Mullins / Islander

- Michael HartungSniffler

- Garett HawePatches

- Dominique KelleyEnsemble


- Marty LawsonEnsemble

- Gary MilnerThe Vicar / Islander


- Michael MundayEnsemble

- Andrew PirozziEnsemble


- Daniel QuadrinoBunting

- T. Oliver ReidOliver Shreeks / Islander


- C. J. TysonEnsemble

- Matt WallSkylights / Islander

- Keenan D. WashingtonEnsemble

- Charlie WilliamsEnsemble

- Alex WongEnsemble


- Helen AnkerDancer / Chorus


- Stephanie KimDancer / Chorus

- Sarah O'GlebyDancer / Chorus


- Kathryn TerzaMermaid / understudy Tiger Lily

- James Brown IIIIslander / Pirate

- Henry Gottfriedunderstudy Peter Pan/swing for lost boys

